The Pony and the Starling

 

Written by Jennifer McGrath

Illustrated by Kristina Jones

Groundwood Books

978-1-773069791

36 pp.

Ages 3-6

February 2025

 

Once you start reading The Pony and the Starling, you'll realize that this story is very personal for author Jennifer McGrath. While her earlier books–I've reviewed The Snow Knows, Pugs Cause Traffic Jams, and highly recommend her middle grade novels Chocolate River Rescue and White Cave Escape–have all suggested personal connections to places and characters, this one seems to have been written from the heart where I suspect the pony and a little starling still live.

From The Pony and the Starling, written by Jennifer McGrath, illustrated by Kristina Jones

A beautiful gray pony lives in a green pasture. A little girl cares for it, providing food and water, shelter and love, as well as visiting with the dog. 

From The Pony and the Starling, written by Jennifer McGrath, illustrated by Kristina Jones

When the fall comes, mother and child admire a murmuration of starlings as they create clouds of shapes that twist and turn. The starlings who enjoyed the fall bounty of peaches, grapes and tomatoes stay only for a few days before they take off. That is, all but one. One starling hangs around. Day after day it accompanies the pony as it snoozes and drinks water and enjoys the last of the autumnal warmth.

From The Pony and the Starling, written by Jennifer McGrath, illustrated by Kristina Jones

When a snowstorm hits and the pony is safely ushered into its small red barn, the child who had always encouraged the starling to seek out its "crowd" tries to get it to go inside with the pony. But the starling will not come down from the big old maple. When winter is finally fully upon them, blanketing the pasture and land with snow and frost, the pony is alone. 

 

When a new murmuration of starlings appears in the spring, they do not just grace the skies above. They sweep over the fields and engage the pony in their murmuration and leave a new friend–or is it an old friend?–behind.

 

Jennifer McGrath's own pony was the basis for this lovely picture book and you can tell the affection with which the story is told. But beyond her personal connection, Jennifer McGrath makes sure the story is infused with a sweet friendship, albeit an unusual one, and one that reminds us to see beyond the obvious. The child's mother is busy, with household chores, chopping wood, etc. and notices the little starling hanging out far later than the girl who observes the animals' connection and tries to help when the weather turns and puts the starling in danger. Her connection with her pony who is befriended by a starling encompasses both of them, extending her compassion and establishing a closeness beyond species.

I think you can tell from the illustrations and even the title that there is a tenderness to this picture book. BC's Kristina Jones's artwork, hand drawn and painted digitally, lends a warmth and sensitivity that verges on sadness. Her landscapes of expansive green pastures and stark winter scenes give us a sense of place through the seasons. But it's her characters that have the life. There's spirited movement and quiet togetherness, and that's just the pony and the starling. But Kristina Jones's illustrations of murmurations are fervent and evocative of the grandeur of nature.

The title of The Pony and the Starling suggests an innocent story but it's more than that. Jennifer McGrath and Kristina Jones have made us look at how animals can connect with each other and amaze us with their alliances and even bonds. I don't know how the true story of Jennifer McGrath's story resolved but I'm hopeful, as this fictionalized is, that there was a happy ending.